Tuesday, October 13, 2009

CTV Winnipeg Consumerwatch, we’ve got a story for you.

A group of Cre-Comm students and I recently completed a small research project on compact fluorescent light bulbs. As boring as that might seem, it was actually quite interesting.

The purpose of the research project was to attempt to uncover an unknown (or lesser known) aspect about a product; something that consumers ought to know. The vast majority of the information we gathered came from the internet. It reminded me that no matter what subject you are researching on the internet, the research process quickly becomes a game that we all know as, “okay, who wrote this and how credible is it?”

It would be really nice to know for sure how many people actually just throw CFL bulbs in the trash. If I had a ton of money to throw around, aside from renting huge billboards around the city that would be designed simply to confuse people, I would hire a public opinion firm to get my damn answers (something the internet could not do).

I would also like to know if a CFL bulb can actually last 10 years, as some companies claim. I’m pretty sure the research and development people behind CFL bulbs figured out that people don't keep track of details that far back. Unless of course you are that person, that has “the list” of dates and details…

I have to admit, I’ve thrown away CFL bulbs, and I’ve even had one break. Years ago I installed a CFL bulb in a light socket at the end of the stair well that leads to my basement, which was dubbing as a rehearsal spot for the band I was in. The bulb was longer than an incandescent bulb, so it protruded from the opening by about 2 inches. We were returning our gear to the jam spot after a gig one very early morning (perfectly sober and eager to be lifting super heavy equipment), and Jonathon’s stupid heavy guitar cabinet, while being lifted so eloquently, smashed the bulb.

I think we used a vacuum to clean it up, which is exactly what you’re not supposed to do when cleaning up trace amounts of mercury-exposed powder. I simply didn’t know about the risk factors associated with CFL bulbs. I think a lot of people are unaware of the risk factors. And for that reason, I think CTV Winnipeg’s Consumer Watch should produce a feature on CFL bulbs. Inform people of the risks and tell them how they can properly dispose of them.

Monday, October 12, 2009

Drum Mic’ing; trials and tribulations

Getting good drum tones is one of the biggest challenges for recording engineers. There are so many factors that come into play: the sound of the drum set, the sound of the room, the style of the player and the type of gear you use, just to mention a few.

I really enjoy experimenting with different microphones and mixing techniques for getting good drum tones. Here is a picture of how I currently have the drum kit mic’d (sorry for the poor quality photo):

One of the main themes for this mic’ing technique is to eliminate the natural reverberation of the room as much as possible. I don’t hate the sound of the drum room I have, but I don’t love it either. It’s easier for me to eliminate the sound of the room, and then add some ambience later on with a reverb. If I had an acoustically treated room with vaulted ceilings, I would definitely take advantage of the character elements that the room sound has to offer.

Before I get any further, here is a quick run down of the mics that are currently setup on the kit.

Kick: There’s a Shure PZM (or pressure zone microphone) on a folded up towel inside the kick drum. This mic is absolutely perfect for capturing the wet sound of the mallet smacking the kick drum skin. It’s also extremely convenient to use considering it comes with a long proprietary cable that connects to a standard XLR cable, and it doesn’t require a mic stand.

I also have a Shure PG kick drum mic setup near the hole in the front skin. This is the right type of microphone for kick drums, but it’s not a studio quality microphone. “PG” stands for performance gear, which is exactly what this mic was designed for. It’s still good for capturing the “woof” of the kick drum, but not ideal.

Snare: There is a Shure Beta 57 just to the right of the first rack tom, and a KELS HM1 right beside that. The Beta 57 is a dynamic microphone that is great for capturing the attack of the snare drum and is tuned to enhance some crucial high-end frequencies. The KELS HM 1 is a medium diaphragm condenser mic and is tuned for low frequencies (it doesn’t embellish high frequencies at all). Not only does the HM1 reduce the amount of audio bleeding from the hi-hats, but it provides me with a contrast sound to the Shure Beta 57. It’s nice to have options during the mixing process; sometimes I might want to choose only 1 of the mic sounds, and sometimes I might decide to blend the two together.

Rack Toms: I’m using Shure 57 mics on the rack toms. The Shure 57 is arguably the most widely used microphone for studio and performance applications in North America (maybe the world). I don’t always use it on toms, but decided to in the instance.

Floor Tom: On the floor tom I’m using a Sennheiser MD 421 dynamic microphone. This mic differs from other dynamic microphones in a few ways, but for me the big difference is that it contains a hum bucker coil. That coil adds character to the mic, and character is a very good thing for drum tones. It also represents the low frequency spectrum more tastefully than the Shure 57 does, which is why it is frequently used for mic’ing kick drums, guitar amps and bass amps.

Overheads: For overhead mic’ing, I’ve chosen an X/Y technique using a matched pair of Rode NT5 microphones. The NT5 mics are small diaphragm, pencil condenser microphones. I like these mics because of their true representation of the tones of the drum kit. A lot of other overhead mics are tuned to emphasize the high frequencies associated with cymbals. This can be beneficial in a lot of applications, but it can also limit the ways you can use the tones during mix down. I like both kinds of mics, and use each according to their strengths.

Hi-Hats: The reason I left hi-hats for last is that it is the one that has caused me the most grief (hence the “tribulations” in the title). Prior to landing on the one in this photo, I tried the Apex 185 (cheap!), and the AKG C1000. The C1000 simply rubbed me the wrong way on hi-hats. They are very versatile though, and I like having them around for acoustic guitar and congas.

The mic that is currently on the hats is the SE Electronics’ SE3 small diaphragm condenser mic. I bought this mic because I wanted a character mic that isn’t widely used in North America. In fact, at the time I bought this mic, there wasn’t a single company in Winnipeg that sold SE Electronics products.

Similar to the C1000, the SE3 sounds great on acoustic instruments like guitar, and percussion. It doesn’t make the hi-hats sound bad; it just doesn’t make the hi-hats sing. By far my favorite sounding mic on these hi-hats is the AKG C451B. One of my engineer friends has the C451B, and so luckily I get to borrow it for important recording projects. I am constantly swapping gear with friends. It’s really the most economical way to learn about and encorporating gear options for your recording projects.

There isn’t one “right way” to record drums, but there are a lot of wrong ways. The wrong ways usually involve phasing issues, which can happen pretty easily when you have a bazillion microphones on a single source (in this case, the single source is the drum kit in its entirety).

One of the best ways of fleshing out a source’s best tone (whether acoustic or not), is to sweep the microphone over the source. The sweeping technique is a time consuming and tedious process, but is really the best way to find out how the mic responds to the different placements over the source. And here again, there is no best way to mic a source, you are really just trying to get the sound that suits the project.

Fat tones aren’t always the be-all end-all of drum tones. A friend of mine was involved in a project where he was working with a female funk singer, comparable to Remy Shand. They ended up putting a towel over the snare drum to get a dampened effect that was meant to emulate a snare drum from the 70’s. The technique really worked for the project; it wasn’t necessary to have a snare tone that could peel the chrome off of a truck hitch. It just sounded right.

One thousand words later and I’ve only really begun to scratch the surface of drum mic’ing. I guess I’ll have to save pre-amps and in-line compression and EQ for another post.

I bet you can’t wait!

Thursday, October 1, 2009

The sum of all your drives

This blog post might just blow your mind. Consider yourself forewarned.

While I was waiting for the 10 Provencher in front of the MTS center on Tuesday, I began wondering how many gigs of hard drive space I have. So when I got home, I decided to figure it out.

My studio computer has two hard drives, totaling a terabyte worth of storage space (that’s a 1000 gigs).

My old studio computer, (which has been downgraded to an office computer) has three hard drives totaling 200 gigs.

My laptop has a single 80gb drive, and the computer that my fiancé used before we moved in together (which has been sitting unused for months now) has a single 40gb drive in it.

I have two external hard drives that I use to backup studio work; one is 100gigs and the other is 250.

I also have to consider that my MP3 player has a 4gb memory stick in it, and my portable recorder has an 8gb compact flash card.

I have three thumb drives (don’t ask me why), totaling 13 gigs.

So, the sum of all my drives is 1695 gigs of possible storage.

Let me put that in context… the average MP3 file is around 5 megabytes. There are exactly 1024 megabytes in a gigabyte. Hypothetically speaking, if I was to fill all of the potential storage space in my house with Mp3 files, I could store 345, 780 songs.

Here’s where your mind might blow up, so please lay down a mat or something so it’s easier for your loved ones to clean up the mess.

According to a statistic I found on WikiAnswers, they estimate that 365 million people have computers worldwide. Think about how much data in total resides on all of those computers.

That’s pretty staggering when you consider that only a decade ago, Bill Gates was quoted as saying, “'640K is more memory than anyone will ever need”.

Wednesday, September 16, 2009

Auto-tune: An instrument, or a crutch?

Auto-tune (for those who don’t know) is a tool, whether software or hardware based, that allows users to tune or modify the pitch of vocals. It’s been a hot topic as of late, so I think the music geek should weigh in on the subject.

It’s funny to me that such an esoteric topic has made news stories (at least on music radio), because it wouldn’t be an issue had producers not overused it. From what I understand, the Anti-Auto-Tune crowd (music purists I’m assuming) argue, that if you have to use a tool to correct the pitch of a vocalist’s performance, the vocalist couldn’t perform the part and has no business being in the studio. As Henry Rollins put it on William Shatner’s song, I can’t get behind that, “If you have to fix it with a computer: quantized, pitch corrected, and overly inspected, then you can't do it, and I can't get behind that!”

This is a valid point. If you are recording a performer who is pitch challenged, or a novice singer, and you absolutely have to use a pitch correction tool to make that person sound in tune, I would say that you are entering into a world of hurt. If you are this producer, you might want to ask yourself why you are wasting your time trying to polish a terd . Is it really Auto-Tune’s fault, or is the producer using bad judgment? Maybe a more important question is; should the performer practice a lot before trying to become a rock star?

This is a great example of polishing a terd:






In this video, the producer is actually feeding the desired notes into Auto-Tune using a midi track that he recorded using a midi-controller. This is more an example of Manual-Tune, than Auto-Tune. If you listen carefully, you can easily pick up where Auto-Tune is fixing the off-notes.

Remember the days… like when Elvis was king… and you had to be “uber-talented” to even think about recording a song? Well I don’t either, I’m not that old. Recording gear is somewhat affordable and people are consuming music (media in general) at a fiercer pace than ever before, so why not let people record whatever, right?

Consider this; we live in a digital age where audio can be manipulated to within an inch of its life. The vast majority of the music coming out of the world’s most successful production houses, is as Henry said “quantized, pitch corrected, and overly inspected”.


How did music production get to this point? Maybe producers have been polishing terds for so long, that it has driven the industry to find ways to make the poo shinier, faster. Or, maybe someone just wanted to get an edge in a very competitive industry, so they developed a tool to make already great sounding vocal performances pitch perfect.


Which brings me back to the matter at hand…The reason regular people (as opposed to music geeks) have heard about Auto-Tune, is because many producers (as of late) use Auto-Tune as a production technique. You can use Auto-Tune to completely change notes; it makes the Auto-Tune effect very noticeable. The end result bears some similarity to the effect a Vocoder has on vocals. The effect is kinda neat, but not so neat that it needs to be used in every song. It is a technique that has become very trendy; so trendy in fact that they now have an Auto-tune
iPhone app, and guess what, it’s being promoted by T-Pain.

Whether overused or not, producers are using Auto-Tune to create an effect. If producers are using it to create an effect, they are essentially using it like a musical instrument. A lot of people think that the studio itself is an instrument. The tools that are available in the studio are just as crucial when producing an album as a guitar pedal, or a bass amp, or other gadgets that we would obviously characterize as “musical instruments”. So why not Auto-Tune?


I use Auto-tune. There, I said it. I have never used it on a recording of someone that absolutely tanked their part. I try not to take on projects where I’m put in that position. When I worked with the Shouting Ground, I worked with some of the best vocalists in my career. Not only could they sing, but they all had a very good sense of pitch.


The reason I used Auto-tune on that project was because I wanted to make the track as perfect as possible. I am competing against all of the awesome studios in town for business and I’m also trying to portray myself as a professional by making the work I do sound as good as possible. From the musician’s perspective, once the music gets “out there”, the band is competing against every other band in the world. I know people don’t like talking about music as a competition, because it’s art. But grow up, it’s a business, and if people weren’t treating it that way, would musicians even bother to record their art in the first place?


In all of the instances I have used Auto-tune (except for one, which you can ask me about offline), the effect was completely transparent. The singers were so close to being perfectly on pitch, even the most trained ear wouldn’t be able to pick up the Auto-Tune effect. I know what you’re thinking, “so why use it at all if they are that close to pitch perfection?” For your answer, please refer to the last paragraph.
In all of the cases where I used Auto-Tune, I carefully explained to the artists what the plug-in does, and gave them the option. Some artists don’t want to use it, some do.

So what is the right answer? To use, or not to use… The answer is: it depends on the project. As an audio producer, it’s advantageous to know and be familiar with as many of the tools that are developed for the audio production craft. That might be your edge.


Thursday, September 10, 2009

My CreCom grad buddy Doug gots himself a shiny new company

My friend and former bass player (as he will probably always be referred to... it's a band guy thing) Doug Darling just co-founded a media production company with another one of my not-so-CreCom friends Dave Lewis.

The name of the company is Tripwire Media Group.

I am super excited for these guys. They're already burning the midnight oil.

Doug graduated from the CreCom program only a couple years ago. It's amazing what the right personality and a good edumacation can do.

For some reason I've written most of this blog with a country bumpkin accent in my head, so I've misspelled some words intentionally. Having fun with words is just swell.

I'm going to be assisting Tripwire with the setup of their new Pro Tools rig this Saturday (sweet, by mentioning this fact I'm well within the theme of this blog). Their plant is a straight Mac facility, which will be new to me becasue I run Pro Tools on a PC. Let this be foreshadow, as I plan to make a posting on my experiences working with Pro Tools on a PC.

Check out their site, and please pass leads on to these guys, they do great work!

Wednesday, September 9, 2009

the blog I never thought would come

I admit, I probably wouldn't have a blog if it wasn't a CreCom mandate. It's not because I don't think blogs are a good idea, quite the opposite. I'm all for free speech, free mediums for people to express and share ideas, and well pretty much anything that is free (I'm a true 'pegger; "thrifty"). It just seemed pretentious for me to start a blog that people might read, without bothering to read other people’s blogs. That will change now that I'm on the publishing end.

I'm actually very excited to write about a topic that I'm super passionate about. I'm not actually concerned about whether people will read this or not. If by chance something I write here stems into a constructive debate, then it was totally worthwhile.

The reason I chose a music geek theme for my first blog is because I’ve been recording and playing music in various capacities for about 15 years. I toured with a band called the Velvet Pill around 7 years ago (I think I just dated myself), and more recently produced and recorded an album for Winnipeg band the Shouting Ground.

I'm also interested in video production and have produced a few videos for my past employer. Here's an example of one:





Feel free to let me know if you have any interesting topics for my blog.

I plan to get thick into music geek speak with my first real post.

Enjoy!